The 2018-19 hockey
season has begun and as promised we're taking a look at the all-time
(heh heh) best that can be uncovered from what I like to call the
loser franchises of NHL history, four teams whose existence was brief
and woefully unsuccessful. Those teams are the California Golden
Seals, the Kansas City Scouts, the Cleveland Barons, and the Colorado
Rockies. (Just for the record I was considering including the Atlanta
Flames but as it turns out they were a respectable team. Maybe some
other time.) As per usual we'll take a brief – in this case very
brief – look at each team's history before getting down to brass
tax.
California Golden
Seals (1967-76)
The Seals were a part
of the NHL's original expansion in 1967 when the league doubled from
six teams to twelve. Although the Oakland-based club was the
longest-lived of the four loser franchises it was one of the more
pathetic teams to have existed in the NHL. In its nine seasons it
only made the playoffs twice – knocked out in the first round both
times – and ended up with a total winning percentage of 0.343.
There were a few gifted Seals players over the years but their
abilities were wasted on a team that lacked depth and couldn't come
up with a consistent roster. In fact, Seals players frequently rank
among the lowest plus-minus rated players in league history. Really
they only thing the Seals led the league in was name changes. At
first they were called the California Seals, then the Oakland Seals,
then for just two games they were known as the Bay Area Seals before
settling for good on California Golden Seals. They also changed their
colours/uniforms/logo during their brief existence, which along with
the name changes suggests that management was indecisive and shaky.
Today the Golden Seals are mostly remembered for handing over Guy
LaFleur (draft pick) to the Canadiens in one of the worst trades
ever, and for the fact that they were the first team to showcase
players names on the backs of their jerseys. The last remaining
former Seals player in the NHL was Dennis Maruk and he retired in
1989.
Cleveland Barons
(1976-78)
After plans for a new
Seals arena in San Francisco were scrapped the NHL greenlighted the
franchise's relocation to Cleveland. The team played at the Richfield
Coliseum, the highest capacity arena in the league at the time, but
were barely able to fill half of it due to a constant lack of
promotion and public visibility. In fact, attendance was even worse
than it had been in California. From the start the Barons were rather
strapped for cash, finishing its first season while narrowly avoiding
a players strike due to missed payrolls. Oh yeah, and the hockey
sucked too. In its two seasons the Barons managed a winning
percentage of 0.375 and zero playoff appearances. In 1978 the league
approved a merger between Cleveland and the Minnesota North Stars,
another expansion franchise that was facing financial difficulty. The
integrated team remained in Minnesota and kept the Stars' colours,
uniform, and name. Since then the Cleveland Barons have become
largely forgotten amongst hockey fans (even though they had the
least-bad winning percentage and goal differential of this group of 4
teams). Curiously, Dennis Maruk was also the last active Barons
player – in addition to the last Seals player – in the NHL.
Kansas City Scouts
(1974-76)
You thought the
California Seals were bad? The Kansas City Scouts will put you to
sleep. The Scouts entered the league in 1974 along with the
Washington Capitals. Aaaaaaaaand big surprise, they were brutal. The
Scouts' inaugural season was painful enough but their second season
ended in a 44 game stretch in which they only won a single game!
The Capitals didn't fare much better. This is mostly due to the fact
that a rival hockey league, the WHA, had recently started up in 1972
stretching the pool of available hockey talent thin. In two seasons
the Scouts managed only 27 victories in 160 games (for a comical
0.240 win percentage), went through three head coaches, and averaged
only 8218 attendees per game (less than half the Kemper Arena's
capacity). At the end of the 2nd season the team was sold
and moved to Denver to become the Colorado Rockies. Just like the
Barons the Scouts have pretty much faded into obscurity in the hockey
world. Wilf Paiement was the last former Scouts player in the NHL and
he retired in 1988.
Colorado Rockies
(1976-82)
And now to arguably the
best (i.e. the least worst) of the loser teams. The Colorado Rockies
are certainly the most well-known of this unfortunate lot. I guess
that's still not saying much. After moving from Kansas City the
Rockies spent six seasons in Denver, making only one playoff
appearance – only because they were in a pathetically weak division
– in which they were swept in two games. Though it did have a few
talented stars here and there the team suffered from a chronic lack
of depth and partook in some lousy trades. In spite of its
instability (like revolving door coaches) the team did have a loyal
following and attendance was pretty good. In 1982, the Rockies were
sold and moved to New Jersey where they were renamed the Devils. 1996
saw the retirement of Joe Cirella, the NHL's last remaining former
Rockies player. NHL hockey returned to Denver when the Quebec
Nordiques moved over to become the Colorado Avalanche in 1995, but
many hockey fans today remember the Rockies. If you ask me, it's
probably because of their sweet jerseys.
And now for the
assembly of these teams' all-time best players. I'm going to come
right out and admit that this team kind of sucks. I tried relaxing
the minimum number of total games played with any of these four
franchises to 150 (instead of the usual 200-250) and still the
pickings were slim. As per usual only these men's achievements with
these four teams will count for consideration on this roster. So that
means that there will be no Lanny McDonald to be found here. What a
shame.
Forwards
|
L-R: Maruk, Paiement, Johnston |
Left Wing
|
Centre
|
Right Wing
|
Joey Johnston (CAL 1971-75)
|
Dennis Maruk (CAL 1975-76, CLE
1976-78)
|
Wilf Paiement (KAN 1974-76, COL
1976-80)
|
Gary Croteau (CAL 1970-74, KAN
1974-76, COL 1976-80)
|
Dave Gardner (CAL 1974-76, CLE
1976-78)
|
Al MacAdam (CAL 1974-76, CLE
1976-78)
|
Gerry Ehman (CAL 1967-71)
|
Ivan Boldirev (CAL 1971-74)
|
Bill Hicke (CAL 1967-71)
|
Gary Jarrett (CAL 1968-72)
|
Merlin Malinowski (COL 1978-82)
|
Reggie Leach (CAL 1972-74)
|
In
my opinion the best player available from these teams (who played at
least 150 games) is Wilf Paiement, a decent two-way winger who could
make plays and fight. In his formative years with the Seals and
Barons, Dennis Maurk was already making a name for himself as an
offensive threat (he was also included on my all-time Capitals lineup) . To their left is the capable playmaker Joey
Johnston. Honestly, the rest of the guys here are just passers and
skaters mostly devoid of any physicality or defensiveness. Like I
said, pickings were slim. The most I can say is that Reggie Leach was
just beginning to blossom into the goal-scoring machine he would
later become with the Philadelphia Flyers with his back-to-back 20
goal seasons. In fact a lot of the guys here did better with other
teams!
Honourable
mention: Walt McKechnie
Defencemen
|
L-R: Ramage, Mattiussi |
Rob Ramage (COL 1979-82)
|
Rick Hampton (CAL 1974-76, CLE 1976-78)
|
Dick Mattiussi (CAL 1968-71)
|
Carol Vadnais (CAL 1968-72)
|
Mike Kitchen (COL 1976-82)
|
Ted McAneely (CAL 1972-74)
|
This team's defensive corps seems a bit better staffed than its
forward lines. With the first pairing we have Rob Ramage the
hard-nosed, playmaking grinder and Rick Hampton's offensive
contributions (three seasons of 36+ points, one 50 point season). The
second pairing is made up of Dick Mattiussi, an excellent forechecker
and penalty killer, and tough guy Carol Vadnais. Lastly we've got
Mike Kitchen and Ted McAneely providing some solid stay-at-home
defence on the third pairing.
Honourable
mention: Doug Roberts
Goaltenders
|
Smith |
Gary Smith (CAL 1967-71)
|
Gilles Meloche (CAL 1971-76, CLE 1976-78)
|
If I recall correctly these two were the only goalies that qualified
for consideration under the 150-game rule. And in spite of Meloche's
longevity (and the fact that I picked him as backup for my all-time Minnesota North Stars team), I chose Gary Smith as the starting netminder. His
goals-against average was lower, he posted shutouts more frequently
(nine in four seasons against Meloche's eleven in eight), and he also
played 65+ games twice.